Skip to Content
Closeouts - Hard to Find Cigars
Finding the right cigar for you is always an exciting adventure. But finding those rare gems? That could be a tad bit exhausting and frustrating. These “unicorns” of the cigar industry may be so hard to find because they’re collected privately and remain in the small circles of the cigar industry.
List By:

Aladino Corojo Reserva No. 4 new

Aladino Corojo Reserva No. 4
SKU: 1211271
Package: Box of 20
Size: 5 x 44
Strength: Full
Shape: Corona

Aladino Corojo Reserva No. 4 delivers a bold, vintage-style Honduran cigar made entirely from authentic Corojo tobacco grown by the Eiroa family. This smaller format packs impressive depth, offering a concentrated mix of earth, pepper, cedar, and a warm natural sweetness that builds as it burns. Its rich, old-school character and clean construction make it a favorite among smokers who appreciate a powerful, flavor-driven experience in a compact size.

$184.90
Retail Price: $257.00
Save: $72.10
Availability: In Stock

Aladino Sumatra Toro

Aladino Sumatra Toro
SKU: 1211121
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

Aladino Sumatra Toro brings a fresh twist to the Aladino portfolio, pairing a rich Sumatra wrapper with the brand’s signature Honduran-grown core. The Toro size allows the blend to open up gradually, offering a smooth mix of earth, light spice, cedar, and a touch of natural sweetness. It’s a well-rounded cigar with enough depth to satisfy experienced smokers while remaining balanced and approachable from start to finish.

$261.90
Retail Price: $367.00
Save: $105.10
Availability: In Stock

Alec Bradley Safe Keepings Toro

Alec Bradley Safe Keepings Toro
SKU: ABSK6052
Package: Box of 24
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Alec Bradley Safe Keepings Toro pays tribute to the brand’s tradition of storing and aging special tobaccos for future projects, resulting in a blend that’s refined, flavorful, and remarkably smooth. This Toro delivers a steady progression of warm earth, toasted nuts, gentle spice, and a faint sweetness that ties everything together. With its clean construction and even burn, it’s a cigar that feels both classic and fresh, appealing to smokers who appreciate balance without sacrificing depth.

$286.34
Retail Price: $401.92
Save: $115.58
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Alec Bradley Safe Keepings Toro 5 pack

$69.89

Artista Harvest Midnight Box Press Robusto

Artista Harvest Midnight Box Press Robusto
SKU: ARTM5054
Package: Box of 20
Size: 5 x 54
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Artista Harvest Midnight Box Press Robusto delivers a rich, evening-ready profile built around a dark, flavorful wrapper and the brand’s careful blending approach. The box-pressed design helps the cigar burn cool and evenly, bringing forward notes of cocoa, earth, roasted coffee, and a touch of sweetness as it opens up. It’s a satisfying, medium-to-full smoke that feels polished and well-rounded, perfect for those who like depth without harsh edges.

$182.11
Retail Price: $253.02
Save: $70.91
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Artista Harvest Midnight Box Press Robusto 5 pack

$54.02

Artista Harvest Sumatra Box Press Robusto

Artista Harvest Sumatra Box Press Robusto
SKU: ARTH5054
Package: Box of 20
Size: 5 x 54
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Artista Harvest Sumatra Box Press Robusto brings a lively, layered profile to the Harvest series, showcasing the natural sweetness and spice of its Sumatra wrapper. The box-pressed shape helps the cigar burn slowly and evenly, allowing its flavors of cedar, light earth, toasted spice, and a gentle sweetness to unfold smoothly. It’s a balanced, medium-bodied smoke that feels both refined and approachable, making it a strong choice for everyday enjoyment.

$182.11
Retail Price: $253.02
Save: $70.91
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Artista Harvest Sumatra Box Press Robusto 5 pack

$54.02

CAO Limited Edition Vision Toro

CAO Limited Edition Vision Toro
SKU: 1213253
Package: Box of 30
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

CAO Limited Edition Vision Toro brings back one of the brand’s most talked-about releases with a modern blend that’s smooth, aromatic, and layered with flavor. The Toro size allows the cigar to open gradually, showing notes of cedar, warm spice, light earth, and a touch of natural sweetness that lingers without overpowering. With its clean burn and refined profile, this limited release offers a polished smoking experience that feels both contemporary and true to CAO’s creative spirit.

$454.40
Retail Price: $642.00
Save: $187.60
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

Castle Hall Connecticut Magnum

Castle Hall Connecticut Magnum
SKU: 1213815
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6 x 60
Strength: Medium
Shape: Gordo
K. Hansotia and the Gurkha team have done an incredible job reviving Castle Hall, a classic Cuban brand. The cigar features aged Dominican tobacco enveloped in a Connecticut leaf for excellent balance between sweet clove notes and traditional cedar and tobacco flavors. You can always count on the quality and construction of any Gurhka cigar, and with its attractive bands and interesting history, this is sure to be a popular choice.
$100.20
Retail Price: $136.00
Save: $35.80
Availability: In Stock

El Titan de Bronze Redemption Robusto

El Titan de Bronze Redemption Robusto
SKU: ETBR5050
Package: Box of 10
Size: 5 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

El Titan de Bronze Redemption Robusto offers a rich, handcrafted experience straight from one of Miami’s most respected boutique factories. This cigar blends depth and balance, opening with notes of earth, cocoa, and warm spice, followed by a mellow sweetness that rounds out the profile. The Robusto size helps the flavors unfold steadily, showcasing the brand’s signature craftsmanship and attention to detail in every draw.

$148.37
Retail Price: $204.82
Save: $56.45
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

El Titan de Bronze Redemption Robusto 5 pack

$84.37

El Titan de Bronze Redemption Toro

El Titan de Bronze Redemption Toro
SKU: ETBR6052
Package: Box of 10
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

El Titan de Bronze Redemption Toro showcases the boutique craftsmanship the Miami factory is known for, offering a longer, smoother expression of the Redemption blend. The Toro format allows the cigar to open gradually, revealing notes of earth, cocoa, warm spice, and a touch of sweetness that deepen as it burns. It’s a refined, medium-bodied smoke that highlights balance, structure, and the artistry behind small-batch production.

$156.80
Retail Price: $216.86
Save: $60.06
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

El Titan de Bronze Redemption Toro 5 pack

$89.03

Esteban Carreras Cashmere Toro

Esteban Carreras Cashmere Toro
SKU: 1213107
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

Esteban Carreras Cashmere Toro lives up to its name with a smooth, silky profile wrapped in a creamy Connecticut shade leaf. This Toro format gives the blend plenty of space to unfold, offering mellow notes of cream, soft wood, and a touch of sweetness layered over a clean, easygoing core. It’s crafted for smokers who appreciate a refined, relaxing cigar with a polished finish and dependable construction from one of the most consistent boutique makers.

$163.34
Retail Price: $226.20
Save: $62.86
Availability: In Stock

Esteban Carreras Chupacabra Maduro Toro

Esteban Carreras Chupacabra Maduro Toro
SKU: 1213183
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6 x 50
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

Esteban Carreras Chupacabra Maduro Toro delivers the bold, smoky character the line is known for, wrapped in a dark, oily Maduro leaf that adds depth and natural sweetness. The Toro size lets the blend open gradually, offering a mix of earth, cocoa, pepper, and roasted notes that build in intensity without becoming harsh. It’s a well-crafted, medium-to-full cigar with a distinctive edge, perfect for smokers who enjoy rich flavor and steady complexity.

$187.98
Retail Price: $261.40
Save: $73.42
Availability: In Stock

J Fuego Gran Reserva Original

J Fuego Gran Reserva Original
SKU: 1214663
Package: Packs of 60
Size: 5 x 44
Strength: Medium
Shape: Corona

J Fuego Gran Reserva Original brings together generations of Cuban-inspired cigar tradition with a rich, handcrafted profile that’s made to stand out. Blended with well-aged tobaccos and rolled with the skill J. Fuego is known for, this cigar delivers a naturally sweet, earthy depth with smooth transitions and an aroma that feels warm and familiar. Its balanced character and slow, even burn make it a go-to choice for anyone who appreciates a classic yet memorable premium smoke.

$167.96
Retail Price: $232.80
Save: $64.84
Availability: Temporarily Out of Stock

La Imperioso Magicos

La Imperioso Magicos
SKU: 1213671
Package: Box of 24
Size: 4.5 x 52
Strength: Full
Shape: Rothschild

La Imperioso Magicos brings back a celebrated My Father–crafted blend with a bold, full-flavored profile that longtime fans still rave about. This compact vitola delivers concentrated notes of dark chocolate, espresso, and peppery spice, all wrapped in a lush, oily wrapper that adds depth and aroma. Its rich character, steady burn, and small-format intensity make it a standout choice for smokers who want a premium cigar that hits with flavor from the first puff to the last.

$189.49
Retail Price: $263.56
Save: $74.07
Availability: In Stock

Luciano The Dreamer Hermoso No. 4

Luciano The Dreamer Hermoso No. 4
SKU: 1213758
Package: Box of 15
Size: 5 x 48
Strength: Medium
Shape: Robusto

Luciano The Dreamer Hermoso No. 4 brings a refined, artisanal touch to a petite format, offering a smooth and contemplative smoke that highlights the brand’s meticulous approach to blending. This cigar delivers a naturally sweet aroma with layers of cedar, soft spice, and creamy cocoa, all presented with an elegance that has made The Dreamer series a favorite among enthusiasts. Its smaller size doesn’t rush the experience—instead, it showcases the blend’s nuance with a clean, focused finish that feels both luxurious and approachable.

$154.10
Retail Price: $213.00
Save: $58.90
Availability: In Stock

Oscar Valladares McFly Toro

Oscar Valladares McFly Toro
SKU: 1211003
Package: Box of 20
Size: 6 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Toro

Oscar Valladares McFly Toro brings a retro-inspired vibe to a modern premium blend, offering a lively mix of flavor and personality in every draw. Wrapped in a silky leaf with rich Nicaraguan and Honduran tobaccos underneath, this Toro delivers a smooth balance of sweetness, spice, and earth, all carried by a cool, even burn. It’s a cigar that stands out not only for its eye-catching presentation but for a profile that stays engaging from start to finish without overpowering the palate.

$206.46
Retail Price: $287.80
Save: $81.34
Availability: In Stock

Sabor Cubiche Cafe Con Leche

Sabor Cubiche Cafe Con Leche
SKU: SABCUB
Package: Bundle of 20
Size: 4 x 40
Strength: Mild
Shape: Corona

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO HAWAII OR UTAH

Sabor Cubiche Cafe Con Leche offers a smooth, coffee-infused experience that leans into warm, creamy flavors without sacrificing the natural character of premium tobacco. Each cigar delivers an inviting mix of roasted coffee, soft sweetness, and light spice, making it an easygoing choice for anyone who enjoys a mellow, aromatic profile. With its balanced draw and approachable strength, it’s a cigar that pairs effortlessly with your morning cup or an evening unwind.

$27.75
Retail Price: $32.50
Save: $4.75
Availability: In Stock

Tampa Trolleys Churchill

Tampa Trolleys Churchill
SKU: TT7252
Package: Bundle of 20
Size: 7.25 x 52
Strength: Medium
Shape: Churchill

Tampa Trolleys Churchill delivers a classic, easygoing smoke inspired by the timeless cigar heritage of Tampa. This long-format cigar offers a mild, smooth profile with gentle notes of cedar, natural tobacco, and a hint of sweetness that makes it ideal for everyday enjoyment. Whether you’re settling in after a long day or looking for a reliable companion to your morning routine, Tampa Trolleys Churchill provides a satisfying experience without any harsh edges.

$59.66
Retail Price: $78.08
Save: $18.42
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Tampa Trolleys Churchill 5 pack

$20.13

Winston Churchill Lancaster Belicoso

Winston Churchill Lancaster Belicoso
SKU: WIN4546
Package: Tins of 20
Size: 4.5 x 46
Strength: Medium
Shape: Belicoso

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED INTO NEW YORK

Winston Churchill Lancaster Belicoso brings together refined craftsmanship and rich, traditional flavor in a shape that highlights both depth and balance. This belicoso is inspired by the timeless character and bold legacy associated with its namesake, offering a smoke that opens with smooth earthiness before unfolding into notes of wood, spice, and a touch of natural sweetness. Its tapered head concentrates the aroma and enhances each draw, making it an excellent choice for smokers who appreciate a cigar with presence yet polished restraint.

$170.30
Retail Price: $236.14
Save: $65.84
Availability: In Stock
5 Pack

Winston Churchill Lancaster Belicoso 5 pack

$50.75

Woody by Oscar

Woody by Oscar
SKU: OVW21100
Package: Box
Size: 21 x 100
Strength: Medium

THIS ITEM CANNOT BE SHIPPED NTO NEW YORK

Woody by Oscar is one of the most striking cigars on the market, known just as much for its oversized, eye-catching presentation as for its smooth, flavorful profile. Handcrafted in Honduras, this long and impressive cigar delivers a relaxed, easygoing smoke with layers of natural tobacco sweetness, light earth, and gentle spice. Despite its size, it burns evenly and offers a mellow-to-medium character that makes it approachable for seasoned smokers looking for something unique as well as fans of novelty cigars who still want genuine quality.

$64.56
Retail Price: $85.08
Save: $20.52
Availability: In Stock
Showing 1 to 19 of 19

Disclaimer

TheCigarStore.com does not sell tobacco products to anyone under the age of 21. TheCigarStore.com does not sell cigarettes. It is unlawful to purchase cigars below the minimum age. If you are not at least 21 years of age, please do not enter our site.